Middletown police chief: Pride performers did not break law

Chief David Birk says he received numerous complaints from residents regarding dancers.
Natalia Milian performs on stage during the drag show at Governors Square for the 5th annual Middletown Pride celebration Friday, June 23 2023. NICK GRAHAM/STAFF

Credit: Nick Graham

Credit: Nick Graham

Natalia Milian performs on stage during the drag show at Governors Square for the 5th annual Middletown Pride celebration Friday, June 23 2023. NICK GRAHAM/STAFF

Middletown Police Chief David Birk said he received “a ton of calls” from upset residents following Middletown’s Pride event Friday night.

Most of the callers were upset about dancers, some in drag, performing on stage with children in the audience. When pictures of children giving the dancers dollars surfaced on social media and websites, that fueled more frustration from locals.

Birk said he contacted the Butler County Prosecutors Office, Butler County Children Services and Middletown Division of Police juvenile detectives to make sure the activity was legal. He was told that if the dancers didn’t expose their genitalia, didn’t have any physical contact with the spectators and didn’t distribute material, the activity was legal.

“I can’t find any criminal offense at all in reference to the Pride event,” Birk told the Journal-News. “No laws have been violated.”

He said police gave one criminal summons to a man, who despite being warned by police, continued using a megaphone, a violation of a city ordinance.

During the 2019 Pride event, John M. Williams, then 42, was arrested and charged after he allegedly generated unreasonable noise with a megaphone. The charge was a fourth-degree misdemeanor.

About the Author