Calabria Pizza opens on Hamilton’s west side

New restaurant features New York-style pizza among other things.
Calabria Pizza opened on Thursday, Jan. 9, 2025, in the former Milillo’s Pizza location at 1010 Main Street on the west side of Hamilton.  Pictured is Mensur Demnika, one of the partners of Calabria Pizza, on opening day. MICHAEL D. PITMAN/STAFF

Credit: Michael D. Pitman

Credit: Michael D. Pitman

Calabria Pizza opened on Thursday, Jan. 9, 2025, in the former Milillo’s Pizza location at 1010 Main Street on the west side of Hamilton. Pictured is Mensur Demnika, one of the partners of Calabria Pizza, on opening day. MICHAEL D. PITMAN/STAFF

A pizza restaurant has opened on Hamilton’s west side that features a signature New York-style pizza.

Calabria Pizza opened on Thursday, Jan. 9 at 1010 Main St., a familiar location for longtime Hamiltonians as it’s where Milillo’s Pizza, which had served generations of families, operated from the late 1960s until it closed in 2023.

“We saw the need,” said co-owner Fitim Islami.

Because the 2,000-square-foot restaurant had been a popular pizza restaurant for decades, that history attracted Islami and his business partner, Mensur Demnika. “It’s famous,” Islami said of the building, adding it also helps to be along a high a high-traffic corridor.

Deminka, who is also an owner of Napoli’s Pizza in Miamisburg, said the pizza business is one he knows well. It’s a communal food “and people love pizza,” he said. “Kids, young, old, everybody loves pizza.”

Those who are familiar with Napoli’s will have an idea what Calabria offers. But being new to Hamilton, Deminka said he recommends a few different types of food for first-time customers.

Anyone looking for pizza, which features homemade dough and Grande cheese, should start off with either the New York-style cheese pizza. Other popular pizzas are meat lovers, bruschetta and their white pizza, which has ricotta and spinach.

They also have calzones.

Those in the mood for something other than pizza and calzones could try one of the several types of salads or the four-way pasta, Demnika said, “so you can try all kinds of pasta in one dish.”

Calabria’s is open noon to 9 p.m. six days a week, Tuesdays through Sundays. They can be reached at 513-795-6017 or 513-795-6015, or orders can be made online at bit.ly/OrderCalabriaPizza.

About the Author