Grand jury indicts immigrant deported 7 times on aggravated murder in Hamilton death

Fermin Garcia-Gutierrez, 46, now charged with aggravated murder in a Hamilton case, is shown on a poster prepared by Butler County Sheriff Richard Jones and featured at a press conference March 29, 2024. Garcia-Gutierrez has been arrested several times, deported and arrested again, Jones said. NICK GRAHAM/STAFF

Fermin Garcia-Gutierrez, 46, now charged with aggravated murder in a Hamilton case, is shown on a poster prepared by Butler County Sheriff Richard Jones and featured at a press conference March 29, 2024. Garcia-Gutierrez has been arrested several times, deported and arrested again, Jones said. NICK GRAHAM/STAFF

An immigrant Butler County’s sheriff said has been deported seven times has been indicted on six felony counts in the death of a man found in a Hamilton garage in the spring.

Grand jurors indicted Fermin Garcia-Gutierrez on charges of aggravated murder, murder (two counts), felonious assault (two counts) and kidnapping, with firearm specifications.

In April, Garcia-Gutierrez, 46, was arrested in the slaying of Fernando Reyna Oviedo. Days before that, on March 29, Garcia-Gutierrez was highlighted by Butler County Sheriff Richard Jones, who said Garcia-Gutierrez entered the country illegally multiple times and was deported to Mexico but returned.

Oviedo, 41, had been found dead on April 1 after Hamilton police officers were called about a body in the 1100 block of South 13th Street.

Investigators believe two days before Garcia-Gutierrez was arrested other charges, he committed the homicide.

Fermin Garcia-Gutierrez, 46, is an illegal immigrant and is charged with aggravated murder, in connection with the death of a person found in the 1100 block of South 13th Street in Hamilton. PROVIDED

icon to expand image

Jones said Garcia-Gutierrez is an example of the sheriff’s frustrations with the Biden Administration’s immigration enforcement and border policies.

Jones said Garcia-Gutierrez had been to prison three times and deported seven times to Mexico, but keeps returning.

“Says it takes him two weeks to get back,” the sheriff said then.

About the Author